Custom assortments

Build a custom cookie box

Pick your box size, split the cookies across your favorite flavors, and add the finished mix to your cart. Simple, focused, and made for birthdays, office treats, family nights, or anyone who wants a little of everything.

Back to menu

Choose 6, 12, 18, or 24 cookies.

Mix any available flavors.

Check out for Florida shipping or delivery.

Build a Box

Mix every favorite into one box

Create a custom assortment with a minimum of six cookies. Choose a 6, 12, 18, or 24-cookie box, then split the count across Biscoff, Fruity Pebbles, Chocolate Chip, S'mores, and Mint Oreo however you like.

Choose a mixed box size

6 Cookie Starter Box$3.00 each$18.0012 Cookie Share Box$2.50 eachMost popular$30.00Save $618 Cookie Gift Box$2.33 eachGreat for gifting$42.00Save $1224 Cookie Party Box$2.17 eachBest value$52.00Save $20

6 cookies left to choose.

Biscoff Cookies

A cozy brown-sugar cookie with cookie-butter richness, creamy white chocolate, crunchy Biscoff pieces, and a silky caramel-style drizzle.

Fruity Pebbles Cookies

A soft, cheerful cookie rolled in bright Fruity Pebbles for a playful cereal crunch, sweet vanilla notes, and a colorful bite that feels instantly nostalgic.

A close-up of a large chocolate chip cookie covered with glossy chocolate chips.

Chocolate Chip Cookies

A thick bakery-style classic with a tender, chewy center, golden edges, and plenty of melty chocolate chips in every satisfying bite.

S'mores Cookies

A campfire-inspired favorite with chocolate chip dough, soft marshmallow pockets, and a Hershey's piece on top for that familiar s'mores feeling.

Mint Oreo Cookies

A cool cookies-and-cream cookie with mint creme pieces, dark Oreo crumbs, and a refreshing chocolate crunch that tastes rich without feeling heavy.

First-bake list

Want first notice when custom boxes open?

Add your favorite mix to the cart, then join the list with the box size and notes Sarah should see first. It is the easiest way to keep the custom-box conversation going after checkout.

Allergen notice

Cookies are homemade in a kitchen that may handle wheat, milk, eggs, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. Please contact Sarah before joining with a box idea if an allergy or sensitivity could affect your cookies.